The Shocking Truth About Public School vs. Homeschooling: What the Numbers Reveal

The Shocking Truth About Public School vs. Homeschooling: What the Numbers Reveal

In today’s educational landscape, parents have more choices than ever before regarding how their children learn. For many, the debate between public schooling and homeschooling is ongoing. When we step back and examine the numbers, the disparity between the two is staggering.

Public schools spend an average of $17,280 per student per year. In contrast, homeschooling costs approximately $1,000 per year. Yet, despite the significant financial investment in public education, the literacy rates tell a very different story. Only about 33% of public school students are literate, whereas 99% of homeschoolers achieve literacy. How can this be? What is happening within our school systems, and why does homeschooling produce such dramatically different results?

In this blog post, we’ll break down these statistics, explore why public schools are struggling, and uncover why homeschooling is producing such high-achieving students. If you’re on the fence about homeschooling, these facts might just give you the clarity you need.

Public School Spending: Where Is the Money Going?

One of the most surprising statistics is the massive difference in spending between public schools and homeschool families. With over $17,000 per student being poured into public education annually, you might assume that schools are offering top-tier resources, small class sizes, and excellent instruction. But the reality is far from that.

So, where does this money go?

- Administrative Costs – A significant portion of funding goes to pay for administrators, bureaucrats, and non-teaching staff. In some school districts, administrative expenses exceed teacher salaries.

-Building Maintenance & Operations – Public schools require constant maintenance, security, and utility costs, which can consume a large portion of the budget.

-Standardized Testing – Many schools allocate excessive funds toward preparing for and administering standardized tests, often at the expense of real education.

Programs & Services – While some of these services (like special education) are necessary, others are bureaucratic initiatives that have little to do with actual learning outcomes.

The problem isn’t that we don’t spend enough on public education—it’s that the spending is often misallocated. With such large budgets, one would expect higher academic achievement, but the statistics tell a different story.

The Public School Literacy Crisis

Perhaps the most alarming statistic is that only 33% of public school students are literate. This means that nearly 70% of students are struggling with reading comprehension, critical thinking, and basic literacy skills that are foundational to future success.

How is this possible? Several factors contribute to this crisis:

1. One-Size-Fits-All Education – Public schools teach to the average, meaning students who struggle get left behind, and those who excel are often held back.

2. Overcrowded Classrooms – Many teachers have 25-35 students in a single class, making individualized instruction nearly impossible.

3. Standardized Testing Focus – Rather than teaching deep comprehension, schools focus on test-taking skills, leading to shallow learning.

4.Lack of Parental Involvement – Many public schools discourage parental involvement or limit it, making it difficult for parents to step in and support their child's learning.

5. Curriculum Issues – Schools often use politically driven curricula that prioritize ideology over practical literacy and life skills.

Public schools are failing to equip students with even the most basic of skills, and this failure is having long-term consequences for our society.

The Homeschool Advantage: Why 99% of Homeschoolers Are Literate

On the opposite end of the spectrum, 99% of homeschooled students achieve literacy. Why does homeschooling produce such dramatically better results?

1. One-on-One Instruction – Homeschooled students receive direct, individualized attention, ensuring that no child falls behind.

2. Mastery-Based Learning– Instead of being pushed along with the crowd, homeschoolers move at their own pace, mastering each subject before advancing.

3. Freedom in Curriculum Choices – Parents can choose effective, high-quality curricula that prioritize phonics, comprehension, and real-world skills.

4. A Focus on Reading – Most homeschool families prioritize early literacy, recognizing that strong reading skills set the foundation for all future learning.

5. Parental Involvement– Unlike public schools, homeschooling allows parents to be deeply involved in their child's education, reinforcing learning daily.

6. Faith & Moral Education – Many homeschool families integrate faith and values into their education, reinforcing character development alongside academic excellence.

The flexibility and customization of homeschooling lead to better literacy outcomes, not because homeschoolers are inherently smarter, but because the system is designed for success rather than failure.

The Bigger Picture: What This Means for the Future of Education

The numbers don’t lie. The public school system, despite its massive budget, is failing a majority of students. Meanwhile, homeschooling, which costs a fraction of the price, is producing overwhelmingly successful students.

As more parents become aware of these statistics, we are seeing a growing shift toward homeschooling. Parents are realizing that they don’t have to accept a failing system. Instead, they can take control of their child’s education and provide a superior learning environment.

If you’re considering homeschooling but feel overwhelmed, you’re not alone. Many parents worry about where to start, how to choose a curriculum, and how to balance home education with daily life. The good news is that you don’t have to do it alone.

Call to Action:

🌿 Homeschooling starts with a well-nourished home. When your health, routines, and relationships are aligned, your homeschool flows with more ease and joy. Download the Family Wellness Blueprint—your step-by-step guide to creating calm, connection, and clarity in your home. Because a thriving family is the foundation of a thriving homeschool.